Top 5 Best Down Comforters – Our Comfy Picks & Reviews

Looking for that extra warmth in your blanket to snuggle into during those long, winter months? If so, then perhaps you might want to consider buying a down comforter. Made from down feathers, these comforters are soft and light, but at the same time provide heat to your body while you sleep.

In this article, we will show you our top-five picks for the best down comforters for your bed, addressing the pros and cons as well as our personal opinions for each. Our hope is that you will find it easier when it comes to choosing your own down comforter in the future. Let’s get started!

Best Down Comforters – Our Top 5 Picks

1. Egyptian Bedding Siberian Goose Down Comforter

Weighing only 5 pounds, this particular down comforter from Egyptian Bedding is light and soft, thereby making you make as if you are sleeping on clouds.

Additionally, it is made from 1200 threads, of which its stitches are well-made and durable, so there are few leakages in the fabric. In other words, you do not need to worry about feathers coming out from the comforter, nor needing to clean up the mess!

For the price, Egyptian bedding definitely feels luxurious and warm; especially if you live in an area that is perpetually 60 degrees or lower all-year round, you can be assured that this down comforter will keep you nice and toasty throughout the night.

We bought this down comforter just when the season was just about turning cold. We were impressed with just how lightweight it was, despite its sheer size and fill power (the latter at 750 thereby making it super thick and fluffy, which is just the way we like it). It had no problem keeping us warm when it was 55 degrees in the house.

Our concern is that the fabric covering the feathers is quite loud, especially when we toss back and forth in our bed. It is noisy, as if it were plastic instead of fabric material. While it is not a huge deal, we do find it a bit disconcerting at times when we want to go to sleep.

Pros:

• Lightweight at only five pounds.
• Made from 1200 threads with durable stitching.

Cons:

• Fabric material is loud when moved around which might not be very comfortable.
• Still has a tendency for feathers to leak out of the fabric.
  

2. Egyptian Bedding Hungarian Goose Down Comforter

Also made from Egyptian Bedding, this down comforter has an 800 thread count as well as up to 50 ounces of fill weight, thereby keeping the product soft and puffy for the perfect good night’s sleep.

Granted, it is a bit heavier compared with other comforters at a little over 10 pounds, but in any case, this particular item is sure enough to keep you warm and toasty for even the chilliest nights at home.

Pure white and with straight lines gracing its surface, this down comforter is no-frills and simple in design, only used for convenience of staying warm while not being a hassle of shedding feathers from the inside.

After purchasing this down comforter, we decided to try it out, using it during one of the colder nights of the year. While a bit smaller than other down comforters (such as its 1200 thread count equivalent), it nevertheless covered out bed and kept us pretty warm for the entire night.

While we did not find the straight-line design to be a problem, some consumers might wish for one with a baffle box construction, which help to keep the down fill from slipping every so often. It is a matter of personal preference, and we did not mind not having it at all.

Pros:

• Up to 50 ounces of fill weight.
• No-frills, pure white, and simple in design for sleeping convenience.

Cons:

• A bit heavy at 10 pounds.
• Does not come with a baffle box construction.

3. Puredown White Goose Down Comforter

With a dimension of 90-by-90 inches and a 600 fill power, Puredown’s down comforter is well-lofted and big enough to cover you up for comfort while sleeping at night.

In addition, it is made from white goose feathers, which are luxuriously soft and offers just the right amount of warmth that can be used all-year round. Not too hot and not too soft; that is how it should be!

This down comforter also has a 500 thread count with baffle box construction. Even more so, it has four corner tabs to anchor your duvet to it, a good asset to have considering that other down comforters do not come with this option.

We bought Puredown’s down comforter and we must say that it is quite nice. Soft and spacious, this product gave us the perfect sort of warmth that we needed in all seasons, from the hot summers to the cold winters. The corner tabs to hook the duvet onto was a plus, too.

On the other hand, the down comforter isn’t actually made from 100% down, but rather more precisely 75% and above. Some people might be disappointed with this, as well as the fact that it is rather thin, as the fill power is not all the way up to its potential when taken out of the box.

Pros:

• Provides medium-warmth that can be used all-year round.
• Has four corner tabs to hook your duvet on.

Cons:

• Product information (e.g. down quality, fill power) might not be accurate.

4. Pacific Coast European Down Comforter

Pacific Coast’s down comforter has a 420 thread count, along with a baffle box design that is sure to help prevent your down fill from slipping all over the place. By having pockets in which down feathers can be stuffed, it takes away the problem of uneven weight distribution. As a result, this product will keep your body equally covered from head to toe during cold nights in bed.

This down comforter also has excellent fill power which contributes to its good loft, or “fluffiness.” Even better, it is also light in weight at no more than 6 pounds, which makes it manageable to transfer between beds or for cleaning.

Size-wise, it is quite large and is able to easily cover a full queen-sized bed. That way, you will not need to worry about your neighbor hogging up the blankets in the middle of the night anymore!

We purchased Pacific Coast’s down comforter, and liked how it has a baffle box construction to keep the down fill from moving around within the fabric. It was very light and easy to take out and place onto our bed. Its puffy, but warm features get a solid A, in our opinion!

However, we admit that it is a big too thick and at times we would get too hot in the comforter at night; we would have to use half of it just to feel the right temperature! In addition, the down fill still slips a bit despite the baffle box and we have had to smooth it out several times to make it even again.

Pros:

• Baffle box construction for steady coverage throughout the comforter.
• Excellent fill power for good loft.
• Covers a full-sized queen bed.

Cons:

• Down fill still slips even under the baffle box.
• Gets too warm sometimes.

5. Pinzon Hypoallergenic White Goose Down Comforter

Made from a 100% cotton cover (consisting of 75% goose down feather and 25% down fiber fill), Pinzon’s down comforter offers a solid, neutral warmth to help you feel comfortable during all four seasons.

In addition, its trademarked PermaBaffle provides a good baffle box design to keep the filling locked in. Therefore, you will not have a problem with the filling shifting all over the place as you sleep.

Even further, it is hypoallergenic which means that it fulfills the manufacturer’s sanitation process to make sure that there is no dust, dirt, dander, and other debris inside of the product. That way, you can assure yourself that you are purchasing the cleanest, up-most quality of down comforter.

For us, we bought Pinzon’s down comforter and as soon as we began using it, we saw a notable difference. The baffle box construction is very solid, as we never experienced any sort of down shifting around inside the comforter, at least so far. It is also immaculate, which definitely lives up to its hypoallergenic reputation.

Our only problem is that it easily sheds feathers from the inside; we have had to clean up after ourselves many times already and it would have been preventable if the product were better sewn.

Pros:

• Good-quality baffle box design; no slippages whatsoever.
• Hypoallergenic, so cleanliness is given.
• Medium-warmth for all seasons.

Cons:

• Feathers easily shed from the fabric.

Benefits of Down Comforters

Before digging in the benefits of down comforters, we are going to show you something about the fabric and construction of a down comforter. 

What is the construction of a down comforter?

It is a bed covering that is filled with soft and fine down feathers. These down might be standard down or goose down. In case you do not know, down is the bird’s feather lying under its tougher exterior feathers.

Let’s move on to the many benefits of down comforters and what make them so desirable.

Lightweight

The very first benefit of a down comforter is that it is incredibly light and manageable. When it comes to extra warmth, we often think of bulky and heavy material. Luckily, these comforters have down feathers which use their height and loft to hold the heat inside while reducing the overall weight.

Besides that, these soft and light feathers make absolutely no sound, which comes in handy when you get up at midnight without disturbing your bedfellow.

Warmth

In the winter, you might need layers of blankets to keep yourself warm. It  not only makes it hard for you to breathe and but also overheats your body. If you live in a cold climate area then you should consider silk comforters since they act as an insulator along with your body to keep your warm.

But when you own a quality down comforter, you will instantly notice its amazing heat-capture ability. Down fill is lightweight, but it completely prevents warmth from escaping. Just one layer of appropriate size and thickness can provide you with more than enough heat to stay cozy all night long.

Breathability

Although many different fabrics can keep you warm at night, they may have a frustrating problem of breathability. They may keep your skin warm, but they also keep sweat and moisture inside, which is extremely uncomfortable.

On the contrary, down comforters are highly breathable, and they can perfectly evaporate sweat and moisture from your skin. It also helps maintain your body temperature and keep you dry through the night. 

Durability

Down comforters are also something that lasts for years. The feathers are secured at their position while washing by the quilts and stitches. That is why the comforter can stay balanced and fluffy for a long time. A down comforter would save you a bunch of money in winter for the next few years.

How To Choose The Best Down Comforter

Down comforters have a luxurious, classy and cozy look. Some of them are expensive yet worth every penny. But if you are looking for an affordable choice, there are lots of options left for you to consider.

Here we point out some important criteria for choosing the best down comforter for your bed.

Quality of feathers fill

High quality down is gathered from mature duck or goose. Each bunch of down has a three-dimensional structure that traps air and heat inside.

Every down comforter has a fill power number on its label, which refers to the quality of the down used in the comforter. The higher the fill power, the larger and better the down. A higher rating often means a fluffier and warmer comforter.

A mid-level comforter will have a rating of about 500 while the expensive down is generally over 700 cubic inches. A thin and light comforter is enough to keep you warm during autumn months, though you will need one with more fill to get through the next frosty winter.

Outer fabric thread count

It is crucial to buy a cover that has a high thread count so that you will not need to worry about fine feathers leaking out.

The comforter fabric will be much tighter with a higher thread count. Therefore, you should look for a comforter with a thread count above 300. Note that a higher thread count means that your comforter is more pricey.

Comforter design to keep down in place

The design of a comforter decides how down feathers are packed inside it as well as its durability. Common comforter designs are baffle box, square, or diamond box. All of them ensure that down is not clumped or shifted to any corners.

Wanted size and weight

The best down comforter should be lightweight to suit the temperatures outside. It also has to fit your bed, so you should not purchase a comforter by size labels. Instead, you should take careful measurements and look for the one that matches your bed size closely.

A lightweight comforter is perfect for those slightly cold autumn nights. A regular-weight is for cozier nights when winter winds blow outside. There are also summer-weight comforters, which are ideal in the summer.

Check your budget

Before deciding on a purchase, you should think about how much you would like to spend on a down comforter. Are you going for a superb down comforter, which is above $300 or something more affordable?

The comforter’s thread counts, down quality, and fill power directly affect its price. But the cost always goes hand in hand with the quality and durability of your comforter so, an expensive comforter will be worth every penny you paid.

Conclusion

Buying a down comforter for your bed requires knowing a few key components in order to get one that will last you for many years to come. From thread counts to baffle box to fill power, all of these aspects are taken into account so that you can find one best down comforter for you. Now that you know what you want and need, it is now time to look around!